Canada has pledged to accept thousands of refugees from dangerous situations and war in Ukraine and Afghanistan, but what is it doing to help and house them once they arrive?
Two recent webinars — by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and Urban Land Institute (ULI) Toronto — explored progress to this point and what can still be done from a real estate perspective.
Many Canadian cities are already challenged to provide adequate amounts of affordable housing to citizens and the more than 400,000 immigrants scheduled to arrive over the next few years.
Calgary Catholic Immigration Society chief executive officer Fariborz Birjandian said resettlement and relief agencies need to engage landlords and building owners to create partnerships and try to come up with solutions.
Where Afghan refugees are settling
Canada plans to resettle at least 40,000 Afghans facing persecution from the Taliban, and the 10,000th of these displaced people was welcomed on March 30. Birjandian said 39 communities outside Quebec have accommodated people so far. The Quebec government has designated 14 communities across the province for resettlements.
The top-five destination communities have been Toronto, Calgary, Vancouver, Ottawa and Mississauga.
Last year the federal government expanded resettlement services to nine smaller communities: Abbotsford, Kelowna, Nanaimo and Surrey, B.C.; Fort McMurray and Grand Prairie, Alta.; Bathurst and Edmundston, N.B.; and Winkler, Man.
IRCC director general Corinne Prince said the network of towns and medium-sized cities able to accommodate refugees is being expanded.
The Resettlement Assistance Program is offered by 35 organizations and assists newcomers by meeting them upon arrival, helping them find suitable housing and offering initial allowances and monthly income support for up to 12 months.
The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) works closely with the housing sector and governments.
Vice-president of policy development Patricia Roset-Zuppa said the key challenges and barriers for newcomers in accessing housing are affordability, overcrowding and hidden homelessness, discrimination, disconnected services and under-utilizations.
“If it wasn’t for CMHC for designing and creating affordable housing, directly and indirectly, and financing and insuring loans, I don’t think we would have had any affordable housing in Canada,” said Calgary-based Mainstreet Equity founder, president and CEO Bob Dhillon.
The federal government’s National Housing Strategy was created in 2017 with a 10-year, $72-billion plan using a human rights-based approach that promotes inclusion, accountability, participation and non-discrimination.
Funding is delivered by the federal, provincial or territorial governments to developers, housing providers, community groups and researchers to create new housing, modernize existing housing and provide resources, data, innovation and research.
Killam Apartment REIT
Halifax-based Killam Apartment REIT vice-president of marketing and program development Jeremy Jackson said the private sector can play a role in supportive housing, affordable housing and market housing.
He deals with settlement agencies and non-profit housing agencies across Canada to assist with partnerships in providing supportive housing.
Killam’s Glenforest Apartments in Halifax is a 400-unit community of 10 older walk-up buildings that has accommodated refugees for 10 years. Jackson said about 70 per cent of current residents fit in that category.
Killam owns apartment buildings across Canada and Jackson said it has vacancies in Calgary, Edmonton, Ottawa and St. John’s where it can help resettle refugees and immigrants.
“Every single corporate developer that’s building multires apartments needs to engage,” said Jackson. “You’ve got to try to help out where you can.”
Almost 44 per cent of Afghan immigrants have a family of six or more, so larger units must be found to accommodate them. However, Jackson acknowledged it’s a major challenge to provide apartments with three or more bedrooms.
He said governments and developers need to work together to build more projects with large units.
Directing refugees to more affordable cities
Dhillon said if Canada can’t provide a safe roof over people’s heads, it will create challenges and make it a weaker country.
“The short-term solution is that we need to direct refugees and immigrants to the right parts of Canada where housing is more reasonable,” he suggested, singling out Manitoba and western provinces, and particularly the northern parts of those provinces.
“Even major urban centres like Calgary, Edmonton, Saskatoon, Regina and Winnipeg still have rents below $1,000 and it’s still affordable. That becomes a stepping stone for them because house buying is affordable.”
Dhillon conceded immigrants and refugees want to live with members of their communities, which is why they often concentrate in the Greater Toronto Area. However, the cost of living is high and he believes cities and towns across Canada are becoming more diverse, which can make them more appealing as well as affordable for newcomers.
Dhillon sees refugees and immigrants as very low-risk tenants and said Mainstreet will take a chance on them even if they don’t have credit references or deposits.
Birjandian said Mainstreet provided five apartments, rent-free for three months, after he asked for assistance.
Amit Thakur, district manager for Toronto-based Morguard, has worked with the Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants to relocate Syrian refugees and is now doing the same with Afghan families, whom he says are thankful to be safe, have housing and able to send their children to school.
He noted many refugees have moved out of apartments and bought houses or condominiums as they became more established.
Organizations supporting Ukrainian refugees
REALPAC CEO Michael Brooks moderated the ULI Toronto panel on Ukrainian refugees and opened by thanking local organizations acting as bridges to real estate, homes and jobs for refugees: BOMA Toronto; the Canadian Urban Institute; the Federation of Rental-Housing Providers of Ontario; the Greater Toronto Chapter of the Commercial Real Estate Development Association; the Ontario Professional Planners Institute; Toronto CREW; Toronto Region Board of Trade; REALPAC; and ULI Toronto.
Olenka Bulat, co-chair of the Ukrainian Canadian Congress (UCC) displaced persons settlement committee, said her organization’s 23 branches are working with governments, community groups and corporate partners on refugee issues.
She expects most Ukrainian refugees to be women with children and perhaps elderly parents.
More than 91,000 Ukrainian refugees had applied to enter Canada, 14,500 had been approved and 11,700 had arrived by March 27 under various visa streams. Those numbers are expected to rise in the next three months; 70,000 Ukrainian refugees could come to Canada, at least temporarily.
The UCC is seeking short-term housing solutions from universities and placing refugees in donated spaces in private homes. It’s also looking for housing industry support via rent forgiveness or assistance.
While many refugees will arrive in Toronto as their Canadian entry point, Bulat hopes housing providers in more affordable markets with more availability will offer accommodations.
UCC CEO and executive director Ihor Michalchyshyn said Canada has a large existing Ukrainian community so some refugees may be able to stay with relatives and friends, at least in the short term, since most will have little savings, cash or resources.
He noted there are well-organized groups in St. Catharines and Oshawa in Ontario, and Winnipeg and Saskatoon further west.
“I think part of that pressure in the GTA will be alleviated if we can work together with the provincial governments that want to redistribute people out to other smaller markets where there might be more availability and where there might be a better quality of life and affordability,” said Michalchyshyn.
“We’re seeing our branches are getting direct messages from people in Europe asking, ‘What is the rent in Winnipeg?’ ‘What is the rent in Vancouver?’ ‘What do I get?’ ‘What kind of jobs are available through the Job Bank?’ ”
Michalchyshyn thinks organized airlifts to cities such as Edmonton, Calgary and Saskatoon would alleviate confusion, rather than having Ukrainian refugees fly into Toronto, then decide where to go.
Supporting refugees upon arrival
League Of Ukrainian Canadians representative Nadia Gereliouk said there will also be a need for commercial and industrial spaces to store supplies and provide services for refugees.
Community infrastructure to provide programming for mothers and children will also be important. There are organizations that can help, but more opportunities would be welcomed.
Toronto Newcomer Office manager Vera Dodic works with the mayor’s office on refugee and immigrant issues and resettlement, and with other levels of government and the Toronto Police Service on support for refugees and streamlining processes.
Brooks said the real estate industry may be able to help provide work for newcomers in construction, property management and security, among other areas. Dodic noted there are agencies that can provide job-matching assistance and the federal government Job Bank can also play a role.
Dodic urged the real estate community to advocate for refugees to receive immediate Ontario Health Insurance Plan access upon arrival, as opposed to having to wait three months.
CAPREIT and its peers
Canadian Apartment Properties REIT (CAPREIT) president and CEO Mark Kenney said his trust provided 10 rent-free, fully appointed apartment units, clothing and groceries for Ukrainian refugee families that had children being treated at Toronto’s Sick Kids hospital – not an easy task considering the low vacancy rate in the city.
These units will be provided, without a need for paperwork, for six months.
Kenney said CAPREIT and peers Hazelview Investments, Boardwalk REIT, Homestead Land Holdings, InterRent REIT, Minto Apartment REIT and Starlight Investments have collectively pledged 400 apartment units across Canada with a variety of incentives to Ukrainian refugees.
CAPREIT, in coordination with the UCC, is offering rent forgiveness and waiving damage deposits, with no paperwork requirements, for 100 units.
CAPREIT and its peers are also attempting to provide job opportunities. Kenney added companies including Sleep Country, Sheraton Hotels, Marriott Hotels, Rogers and Cohen Highley LLP have made generous donations to the effort.
Initiatives are also coming together to provide refugee adults and children with English lessons, adult training programs and schooling for children.
“What a positive experience this has been in a very, very sad set of circumstances,” said Kenney.
Nathan Rotman, who’s involved with public policy in Canada and the Northeastern United States for Airbnb, said the company works closely with its own non-profit Airbnb.org to partner with members of the Airbnb community to offer free temporary housing during emergencies.
Rotman said Airbnb.org has housed over 50,000 refugees and asylum seekers over the past couple of years. It has provided housing to more than 20,000 Afghan refugees and has committed to helping 100,000 Ukrainians.
While most of the housing support for Ukrainians has been in Europe, Rotman said Canadians have been offering housing. As a result, Airbnb.org is working with refugee settlement agencies across the country.